NFL DFS Picks Today: Two Hosts Split Hard On Kyler Murray

Dave Loughran, Ben Rasa, Eric Lindquist, and Chris Spags ran Sunday's Week 1 NFL DFS live-before-lock show off the same board, the same Stokastic Sims, and the same injury news, and still split hard on Kyler Murray (MIN). Eric Lindquist carried him at 15% exposure, stacked with Justin Jefferson (MIN); Chris Spags cut him to 2% and moved that salary to Daniel Jones (IND), Jacoby Brissett (ARI), and Malik Willis (MIA) instead. Neither side moved before lock. The argument was only possible because Las Vegas ruled out Brock Bowers (LV) Sunday morning, turning an already soft-priced 12-game slate into a paydown buffet, with Michael Mayer (LV) at $2,900 and Jahmyr Gibbs (DET) at -300 to score anytime as the two plays nobody argued about. Watch the full live-before-lock show.

The Quick Answer

Two hosts running the exact same live-before-lock desk, looking at the exact same Stokastic Sims, split hard on Kyler Murray (MIN): Eric Lindquist carried him at 15% exposure paired with Justin Jefferson, Chris Spags cut him to 2% and moved to Daniel Jones, Jacoby Brissett, and Malik Willis instead. Neither side blinked before lock. The full breakdown, covering why the split happened, the $2,900 tight end paydown that funded the whole board, and every salary and exposure number from the show, is below.

The Kyler Murray Split Nobody Resolved

Nothing at quarterback consolidated the way tight end did, which is exactly why Murray became the live-before-lock desk's real disagreement. Lindquist paired him with Justin Jefferson (MIN), himself sitting at just 11% ownership ("crazy" for a receiver that talented, in his words), as an easy stack in a 46.5-point game against Green Bay. Spags cut Murray to 2%: "I've got him low… I'm moving away from him for some of the other guys like Shough, like Herbert," he said, adding he preferred Daniel Jones (IND), Jacoby Brissett (ARI), and Malik Willis (MIA) at similar ownership cost.

Spags's case wasn't that a new offensive coordinator caps Murray's ceiling outright: it's that his own rushing volume has been sliding for multiple seasons, down to 5.5 carries a game last year, and the bet is whether Kevin O'Connell's offense reverses that trend or simply inherits it. "Your hope is that he gets this full glow-up that O'Connell can bring to the table," Spags said. "I just don't have the confidence myself." Neither host had a confirmed answer by lock, which is exactly why the field split on him too.

Shough is the row that explains why the Murray disagreement mattered so much: the field's single most popular quarterback still only clears 11% ownership, so the position was flat enough that neither host had to fight the crowd to make a real stand. "This isn't Week 13 of 2025," Dave Loughran said on the morning show. "This is the first week of the 2026 season, and Tyler Shough is popular." Justin Herbert was the other name both hosts kept circling, tied to the Chargers' slate-high 28.5-point implied total against Arizona and Mike McDaniel's arrival as offensive coordinator. Spags had him at roughly 25% exposure, calling Shough and Herbert his two biggest quarterback stands of the morning.

Every exposure figure above comes out of the Stokastic NFL DFS Sims and the NFL DFS projections, ownership and stacks in the DataHub, the same screens both shows ran live.

Get NFL DFS Sims & Projections

The $2,900 Domino That Funded It

That argument only existed because of the salary Bowers' absence freed up. Michael Mayer inheriting targets isn't the interesting part of the news: the interesting part is that his salary was never adjusted for the role he's about to play. "We already had soft pricing," one host said on the morning show, "and now with Bowers out, if you pay down at tight end twice and you punt defense, it's almost pick-whoever-you-want style." At $2,900, four catches and no score still clears the bar most weeks.

An unfiltered Sims run put Mayer in 68% of lineups, and Lindquist ran a batch with 100% Mayer before turning his filters back on. "I'm just jam," he said. "He's my highest-owned player." Most of the field took the savings and bought more of the same three or four chalk names (Gibbs, Olave, Chase) rather than routing it toward the one tight end who actually deserved the bump.

That tight end was Trey McBride, a legitimate WR1-caliber option in a game Arizona is expected to trail most of the afternoon.

Trey McBride projected at just 5% ownership on a slate where the obvious Bowers pivot should have lifted him. The injury everyone reacted to got priced. The one nobody reacted to didn't.

That gap comes back at the end.

Running Back: Gibbs Is The Chalk, Then It Runs Deep

Jahmyr Gibbs (DET) is the least-argued-about great play on the board: he projects clear of the field, sits at -300 to score anytime, and lands at 62% exposure in the Sims. "It's just way too good of a spot," Loughran said. That's high enough to be a real position and low enough to keep outs. There's a version of Sunday where fading Gibbs wins a large-field tournament, but it's a hard place to plant a flag when the cost of being wrong is losing to the slate's most obvious play.

Chase Brown at 7% ownership pays without needing Cincinnati to abandon the run: he holds the backfield and still gets goal-line work even as Joe Burrow spreads the ball between Chase and Higgins. Derrick Henry told a different story in Baltimore: with Lamar Jackson's rushing volume in question after a visibly diminished second half last season, both Rasa and Spags preferred Henry outright over Zay Flowers, betting a new coaching staff leans on the run rather than waiting for Jackson's legs to come back. Jeanty sits opposite that. The Sims like him as the slate's second-best simulated-ROI play, and Lindquist called his own exposure "probably the most unhealthy person on this entire slate," a chalk-driven overexposure he owned on air rather than one built from real conviction.

Take The Cheaper Half Of The Bengals Passing Game

Ja'Marr Chase (CIN) is drawing roughly a third of the field, and there's nothing wrong with him. Tee Higgins (CIN) at $6,300 has real target equity of his own, and the live-before-lock math was pure arithmetic: "I look at $6,300 for Tee Higgins, and right now you are getting a lot of Ja'Marr Chase, because it's not that hard to get up and get him in those doubles and fire it up that way on FanDuel," Lindquist said. When Cincinnati's targets split the way they usually do in a concentrated passing game, Higgins is the discounted version of the same bet.

Nico Collins and Zay Flowers were the pair Spags kept coming back to: "They both have about a 20% sim win rate in my data. I'm getting about 2x the field on both." Both are good players in tough road matchups the field discounted: a proven player at real ownership savings, not a total unknown, which is the trade this slate rewarded everywhere it appeared.

Tight End And Defense: Own Both Sides Of The Mayer Bet

Mayer at $2,900 is the correct chalk. Tre Tucker, the other cheap pass-catcher freed up by the same news, costs under $7,000 combined with Mayer and has real reception equity of his own. Lindquist said he was "fine getting to Michael Mayer and Tre Tucker without Kirk Cousins." The uncertainty at Raiders quarterback didn't matter much at this price.

This is the gap promised earlier, paying off. Arizona opened as double-digit underdogs and the line moved through the 10.5 key number toward 10, against a Chargers team carrying the slate's highest implied total. A team expected to trail most of the afternoon is historically good for its own passing-game usage, and McBride is a real tight end one, not a paydown. "If I were to boost a guy in this game, it's got to be McBride," Lindquist said. Playing well above the field's 5% is the leverage version of the exact same news that made Mayer chalk.

The Browns defense carries its own version of that tension. Cleveland traded away Myles Garrett this offseason and now leans on Jared Verse under new coordinator Todd Monken, and Rasa was candid that the price, not the projection, is doing the work: "I'm playing a shitload of the Browns," he said. "I don't feel good about it. I kind of feel like it's a data lapse... but they're cheap. They're $2,100."

Worked Example: Where The Hosts Went Off The Field On Purpose

The Panthers stack is the clearest build nobody needed to get creative to reach. Bryce Young (CAR) at $5,200 "doesn't even project that poorly," and he's going to be almost entirely unowned in a three-point game against Chicago. Tetairoa McMillan is the receiver the stack naturally runs through, with Jalen Coker as the alternative. Rasa called it going "healthily over the field." The appeal is that nobody else wants to be there.

Three more builds worth naming: Daniel Jones (IND) at $5,400 in that 47.5-point Colts-Ravens game, priced like nobody believes in him despite a near-zero ownership cost; the Nico Collins/Zay Flowers pairing, both around double the field's ownership in tough road matchups; and the Trey McBride pivot at tight end. None require betting on a role nobody has seen yet — they require the field being a little lazy in Week 1, which it usually is.

One practical note: FanDuel's upload tools broke for much of the hour before lock, with CSV imports and manual edits both failing, turning an already competitive contest into a softer field for anyone whose entries were already in. On DraftKings, a full lineup set uploads in one file, and the differences between the two sites mattered more than usual on a slate this flat.

FAQ

Why did the live-before-lock hosts split on Kyler Murray? Because they weighted the same uncertainty differently. Murray's rushing volume has been sliding for years (down to 5.5 carries per game last season), and the open question is whether Vikings head coach Kevin O'Connell's offense reverses that or not. Eric Lindquist stacked him with Justin Jefferson as an easy pairing in a 46.5-point game; Chris Spags moved to Daniel Jones, Jacoby Brissett, and Malik Willis instead. Run the same screens yourself in the Stokastic NFL DataHub with our guide to using the NFL DFS Sims.

Who was the best NFL DFS play for Week 1? The Sims had Jahmyr Gibbs projecting clear of the field at -300 to score anytime, landing at 62% exposure. Michael Mayer at $2,900 was the more slate-altering play, appearing in 68% of an unfiltered run, but Gibbs was the best single player on the board.

Should Michael Mayer have gone in every lineup? No. He was correct chalk worth heavy exposure, but Trey McBride at 5% projected ownership was the pivot the field created by all taking the same Mayer savings, and plenty of lineups worked without either tight end being a max play.

What was the best contrarian NFL DFS stack for Week 1? Bryce Young at $5,200 in a three-point game, where the entire Carolina side was close to unowned, with Tetairoa McMillan and Jalen Coker as the pass-catchers behind him. Daniel Jones at $5,400 in a 47.5-point total was the second option.

Does the slate change after the early games? Yes. Late swap was a real edge on a 12-game Sunday, and both hosts said they'd be adjusting on the fly the moment early-window results came in, particularly around the Kyler Murray question neither of them had resolved by lock.

Build Your Own Lineups

The lesson under both calls: a large share of the field is looking at the same Sims you are, so what you do after that screen is a game-theory decision, not a projection decision. Override the tool when there's a specific, nameable reason the inputs might be stale (a new coordinator, a season-ending injury to a teammate, a line move through a key number), not just to feel contrarian, which is how people end up fading the best player on the board instead of the ones actually worth fading.

Every price, exposure, and ownership figure in this piece came out of the Stokastic NFL DFS Sims, from the Mayer run that hit 68% of lineups to the Kyler Murray split that never got resolved before lock. Run the same screens yourself in the NFL DFS projections, ownership and stacks in the DataHub ahead of next week's board, check the NFL DFS picks hub for the rest of this week's coverage, and the stacking, tight end, running back, and leverage guides are worth reading before next Sunday.

Use code LBLWK1 for 10% off any NFL Core, Max, or MVP package.

Get 10% Off NFL