NFL Week 5 Player Props: Deshaun Watson 40+ Rushing Yards at +280
By Jake Hari
October 6, 2026

My favorite Week 5 prop is a quarterback who runs more than his price says he does.
Deshaun Watson ran 11 times against Carolina last week; only Quinshon Judkins carried more for Cleveland. The Sims expect him to run again against the Jets, and YES on Deshaun Watson 40+ rushing yards at 26.3¢ is cheaper than his real chance of getting there.
Watson's Legs Beat His Arm
| Bet | Kalshi | Chance it wins | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy Yes | Deshaun Watson 40+ rushing yards | 26.3¢ (+280) | 31.2% |
| Buy No | Deshaun Watson 175+ passing yards | 35.6¢ (+181) | 41.4% |
Chance it wins is how often the Sims cash that row's bet. Kalshi prices include the taker fee, as of about 3 p.m. ET Tuesday, Oct. 6. Browns (3-1) at Jets (1-3), Sunday 1 p.m. ET on CBS. Jets running back Breece Hall is doubtful.
Cleveland is 3-1 and leans on the run: Quinshon Judkins and Watson's legs, with short throws in between. When Watson can't find a target, he runs, and the Jets have to account for him on every snap. So I'm buying YES on Watson 40+ rushing yards and NO on Watson 175+ passing yards. He didn't reach 175 against Carolina, and that NO pays almost 2-to-1.
Fannin Is Watson's Outlet
| Bet | Kalshi | Chance it wins | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy Yes | Harold Fannin Jr. 50+ receiving yards | 33.5¢ (+199) | 38.5% |
| Buy Yes | Harold Fannin Jr. 40+ receiving yards | 47.7¢ (+110) | 52.8% |
Buy YES on Harold Fannin Jr. 50+ receiving yards at 33.5¢. When Watson's first read isn't there, the ball goes short to Fannin, and he led Cleveland in catches last week. His whole yardage ladder is priced under the Sims. The 50-yard line is the one I'd buy; 40 is the safer version of the same bet.
Allen Stays Under 80
| Bet | Kalshi | Chance it wins | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy No | Braelon Allen 80+ rushing yards | 64.6¢ (-182) | 70.7% |
Breece Hall is doubtful, so Allen is the Jets' lead back again. The last time he had the job, in a loss at Chicago, he didn't get to 60 yards. A 1-3 team that falls behind Cleveland stops handing off, and 80 yards takes a game the Jets haven't played yet. Buy NO on Braelon Allen 80+ rushing yards; if Hall is ruled active, the carries split and the NO only gets better.
My Take: Three Buys
- Buy YES on Deshaun Watson 40+ rushing yards at 26.3¢ (+280). The best bet on the board: he's priced like a pocket passer and plays like a runner.
- Buy YES on Harold Fannin Jr. 50+ receiving yards at 33.5¢ (+199). The short throws in that same Watson game go to him.
- Buy NO on Braelon Allen 80+ rushing yards at 64.6¢ (-182). The Jets fall behind and stop running.
On Thursday night, my play is NO on Dak Prescott 275+ passing yards at 56.7¢ (-131): Dallas should beat an 0-4 team with a rookie quarterback by running Javonte Williams, not by throwing. It's the lead leg of my same game parlay, linked below.
Build Your Script
Browns-Jets and every other Week 5 game with Sims are in the free Kalshi Combo Simulator. Type the final score you expect, and it builds and prices the props for that script. Or ask the Sims in plain words, like "How often does Deshaun Watson run for 40 yards when the Browns win?"
Hero illustration: comic drawing from a Deshaun Watson photo by Erik Drost (CC BY 2.0), on an Action background. Prices: Kalshi, Oct. 6, 2026.
Week 6 Thursday night: Seahawks vs. Broncos Prediction & Props: Smith-Njigba TD +110
Thursday night: Buccaneers vs Cowboys Prediction & Same Game Parlay · Buccaneers vs Cowboys First TD Scorer
Ask the Sims about any Week 5 player prop and see how often it hits across 10,000 Sims, in the free Kalshi Combo Simulator.
Get Started