Patriots vs Bills Same Game Parlay: Bills Win, No Shootout
By Jake Hari
October 4, 2026

Buffalo is unbeaten and New England comes to town trying to catch up. My read is plain: the Bills win it, the game never turns into a shootout, and the Patriots' run game never gets going.
So I typed that game into the free Kalshi Parlay Simulator and let it build the three-leg same game parlay. Then I flipped the score to see what the upset ticket looks like.
Buffalo Controls It
New England Patriots (1-2) at Buffalo Bills (3-0) Sunday, October 4 · 1:00 p.m. ET · Highmark Stadium · CBS Stokastic Sims: Bills win 68%
Ray Davis is questionable and Tyrell Shavers is out for Buffalo. Neither one touches my legs.
Bills Win It Quietly

I typed in Bills 28, Patriots 21. This is the top card:
| Leg | Side | Kalshi |
|---|---|---|
| BUF wins | YES | 74¢ (-285) |
| Over 54.5 total points | NO | 66¢ (-194) |
| TreVeyon Henderson 50+ rushing yards | NO | 65¢ (-186) |
| Sims price | Kalshi legs | Near 28-21 |
|---|---|---|
| 35.2¢ (+184) | 31.7¢ (+215) | 67% |
When Buffalo wins without a track meet, New England isn't getting Henderson loose, so these three legs show up in the same games. The sims price beats the Kalshi number, which tells me the legs hit together more often than their separate prices imply. That's the bet.
Patriots Pound It

Flip it to Patriots 27, Bills 24 and the top card runs through the backfields:
| Leg | Side | Kalshi |
|---|---|---|
| BUF wins by 6+ | NO | 44¢ (+127) |
| James Cook 100+ rushing yards | NO | 63¢ (-170) |
| TreVeyon Henderson 30+ rushing yards | YES | 67¢ (-203) |
| Sims price | Kalshi legs | Near 27-24 |
|---|---|---|
| 28.6¢ (+250) | 18.6¢ (+438) | 59% |
New England only keeps this close if Henderson gets going and Cook never takes over, and that's the same game where Buffalo can't pull away. It doesn't even need a Patriots win, just a close one. The sims price clears the Kalshi number by a lot, so it's a play.
Build It Yourself
- Open NE @ BUF in the Kalshi Parlay Simulator.
- Type your final score into Pick Your Game Script. Pick the score before the legs, because the legs that make sense change with it.
- Set legs to 3 and read the cards. Sims Price is how often the whole combo hit in 10,000 sims. Kalshi is the three legs bought one at a time, multiplied. Current Script is how often it hit in the sims that finished near your score, so it's the price if you're right.

My Two Tickets
- Bills 28-21 (35.2¢ sims): YES on BUF wins, NO on Over 54.5 total points, NO on TreVeyon Henderson 50+ rushing yards.
- Patriots 27-24 (28.6¢ sims): NO on BUF wins by 6+, NO on James Cook 100+ rushing yards, YES on TreVeyon Henderson 30+ rushing yards.
Prices are from about noon ET on game day, and they move until kickoff. The simulator is free, so type your own Patriots-Bills score and see what it builds.
More on this: Buccaneers vs Cowboys Same Game Parlay: Three NOs, One Game · Cowboys vs Texans Same Game Parlay: Williams Held Under 70 · FanDuel Parlay Simulator: Odds For Every Parlay · NFL Week 6 Anytime TD Scorer Picks & Parlay Cheat Sheet · Polymarket Parlay Simulator: Fair Odds On Every Parlay
Type your own Patriots-Bills score into the free Kalshi Parlay Simulator and it builds and prices the combos, from the same 10,000 sims.
Get Started