49ers Vs Rams Showdown DFS: The Leverage Play Is A Kicker

Writing this Wednesday afternoon, September 9. The 49ers and Rams play Thursday, September 10, at 8:35 p.m. ET, which is 10:35 on Friday morning at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, and the 49ers vs Rams showdown DFS slates are up on both DraftKings and FanDuel. Every number below is from the Stokastic Sims as of Wednesday; they rerun once the final injury report is in.

Nobody has scouted this venue, this hour, or this body clock. Two teams that know each other better than any pair in the NFC West are meeting on a cricket oval on the other side of the world, the Rams as the designated home team, at an hour when most of the American audience is finishing dinner. For a Rams roster landing the day before on Pacific time, a 10:35 a.m. local kickoff feels like 5:35 in the evening, closer to normal than the calendar makes it look. How much any of that matters is a guess, and the Sims do not price it. The 49ers flew early and have been in Melbourne since last Friday. The Rams flew Wednesday and land the day before kickoff. DraftKings has the Rams at -3.5 with a total of 48.5, which puts Los Angeles at 26 implied points and San Francisco at 22.5, a normal divisional number for a thoroughly abnormal week.

The weather is the one thing that is settled. The Bureau of Meteorology's Thursday morning forecast, Melbourne time, for Friday is a high of 17 degrees Celsius, about 63 Fahrenheit, later in the day, with kickoff nearer the 8 degree overnight low, light winds for the day, and a 5% chance of rain. Remember the light winds. They matter for the player who turns out to be the single biggest outlier on this board, and he does not play quarterback, running back or receiver.

Melbourne offer. Code MELBOURNE10 takes 10% off your first payment on any Stokastic NFL or All Access package. The showdown Sims for this game are live, with projections, ownership and captain leverage for both sites. Get 10% off the Sims with code MELBOURNE10.

Week 1 Injury Report: Who Made The Trip

San Francisco's first official report of the season, released Tuesday, had one non-participant, defensive tackle James Thompson (hamstring), and nine limited players. The names that matter for this slate are tight end George Kittle (Achilles), fullback Kyle Juszczyk (finger) and defensive end Nick Bosa (knee). Kittle tore his right Achilles on January 11 and came off the PUP list on August 23, so a limited tag is progress. Christian McCaffrey, Mike Evans, Deebo Samuel and De'Zhaun Stribling were not on the report at all, although NBC Sports lists Evans as questionable with an abductor injury after a camp in which he dealt with a quad problem and then a groin problem. He has said he plans to play. Defensive tackle Alfred Collins was limited on Tuesday and is now out for the year with a torn patellar tendon.

The receivers who are not here are the story of the 49ers' offseason. Ricky Pearsall is out for the season with a knee injury. Christian Kirk is on injured reserve with a calf injury. Brandon Aiyuk is on the reserve/left squad list. That leaves a 33-year-old Evans, a rookie in Stribling, Samuel, Demarcus Robinson and Jacob Cowing as the wideouts the roster capsule counts.

Los Angeles ruled out Aaron Donald, who signed on August 30 after two seasons retired and, per ESPN's report, is not traveling. Myles Garrett did not practice Tuesday and is questionable with a knee, though McVay said on August 31 that the "goal all along has been Australia," and NBC Sports lists him as on track to play. Tyler Higbee, tackle Alaric Jackson and linebacker Byron Young sat Tuesday for rest. Cornerback Jaylen Watson (toe) did not practice and is questionable. Puka Nacua, Davante Adams, Kyren Williams and Matthew Stafford are not on the report.

Los Angeles Rams: 26.0 Implied Points

The favorite, the higher implied total, and the roster that flew last. Everything the field likes on this side runs through Stafford and the two receivers, which is exactly why the Sims' value hides in the cheap pieces around them.

Quarterback

Matthew Stafford is the reigning MVP, off a 4,707-yard, 46-touchdown season, and he turned 38 this year. The Sims project him for 17.5 DraftKings points at $9,800, fourth on the board and inside a point of Brock Purdy. The field has him at 47.4% ownership against 43.6% optimal, the most negative leverage number on the slate. Leverage, everywhere on this page, is the Sims' optimal rate minus projected field ownership: positive means the Sims want a player more than the room does. At captain the field leaves him alone, 6.8% owned for a $14,700 slot that projects to 26.3, and the Sims agree with the field there. He is a fine flex piece in a lineup that rosters Nacua; he is not where I want to spend the multiplier.

Running Back

Kyren Williams cleared 1,000 rushing yards for a third straight season in 2025 with 1,252 and 10 scores on 259 carries, plus 36 catches for 281 yards. The catch is the trend line: he averaged 17.4 touches a game last year against 21.9 in 2024, because Blake Corum took 30.5% of the offensive snaps and turned 145 carries into 746 yards at 5.1 a clip. The Sims are pricing that split into this slate. Williams is $8,600 for 14.2 projected points at 34.4% ownership with negative leverage; Corum is $4,600 for 9.1 at 31.3% with the second-best leverage number on the board.

Wide Receiver

Puka Nacua led the NFL with 129 catches last season on 160 targets, for 1,715 yards and 10 touchdowns, and his 80 first-down receptions were also the most in the league. He is the highest-projected player on DraftKings at 21.3 points and the captain chalk at 26.0%, seven points of captain ownership clear of McCaffrey. Nobody is wrong to captain him. The Sims simply say the field already knows: his captain leverage is slightly negative on DraftKings and at minus 3.5 he is the most over-captained MVP on FanDuel.

Davante Adams led the league with 14 receiving touchdowns in 2025 despite missing three games, on 60 catches and 789 yards. Touchdown-driven receivers are the classic showdown trap: the projection is fine at 13.5 for $9,200, but the ownership at 24.7% is higher than the optimal rate, and his median game is a lot of 40-yard days waiting on one red-zone target. Jordan Whittington, Konata Mumpfield and Tutu Atwell round out the room; Mumpfield at $1,200 is the only one the field rosters with any regularity, at 8.7%, and the Sims' optimal rate on him is lower at 6.2%.

Tight End

This is the deepest and most confusing room on the slate. Terrance Ferguson, the Rams' 2025 second-round pick, caught 11 passes for 231 yards and three touchdowns on 25 targets as a rookie with an average depth of target of 17.5 yards, the deepest for any tight end with 10 or more targets in at least a decade, and most of it came after the Rams went to three-tight-end sets in Week 7. He sat a practice on August 31 as a precaution and is not on this week's report. The Sims split the difference: Ferguson $3,200 and Parkinson $3,600 both project to 5.8, both sit near 23% ownership, but Ferguson's leverage is neutral and Parkinson's is minus 3.1. Higbee at $2,600 is the quiet third option with positive leverage at 13.0% owned.

Kicker And Defense

Harrison Mevis took the job from Joshua Karty in November, went 12-of-13 on field goals and 39-of-39 on extra points the rest of the regular season, then 6-of-6 and 9-of-9 through three playoff games, and the Rams waived Karty and tendered Mevis for 2026. At $5,000 on DraftKings he projects to 9.4 points, more than Kittle, and he shows up in 31.8% of the Sims' top lineups against 14.4% projected ownership. The gap between those two numbers, 17.4 percentage points, is the largest leverage figure on the slate, more than five times the next one. The Rams D/ST at $4,000 projects to 7.4 with mildly positive leverage, a reasonable flex in any lineup that is not captaining Purdy.

San Francisco 49ers: 22.5 Implied Points

San Francisco arrives as the dog with the lower total, and three of the five best captain leverage numbers on DraftKings belong to its players. The reason is concentration: with three receivers gone, San Francisco's touches funnel to two players.

Quarterback

Brock Purdy played nine regular-season games last year, 20 touchdowns against 10 interceptions, and the 49ers went 5-3 in the eight Mac Jones started. Purdy is $9,400 on DraftKings for 18.1 projected points, third on the board, and the number that matters is captain ownership: 10.8%, against 26.0% for Nacua and 18.9% for McCaffrey. The Sims put him in 12.0% of optimal captain slots, which makes him the best quarterback leverage on either site. On FanDuel his MVP leverage of plus 2.2 is second only to McCaffrey.

Running Back

Christian McCaffrey touched the ball 413 times last season, a 49ers record, for 1,202 rushing yards, 10 rushing touchdowns, 102 catches, 924 receiving yards and seven more scores. He was an MVP finalist. Kaelon Black is listed as the RB2 and Jordan James "will juggle carries with Black," per 49ers Webzone's roster capsule, and the Sims project the pair for a combined 2.5 points. McCaffrey is $10,600 for 20.7 points at 46.1% ownership on DraftKings, and unlike Nacua and Stafford, his leverage is positive in both slots. On FanDuel he is the single best MVP leverage on the board at plus 2.5. Captain Purdy with McCaffrey in a flex slot is a correlated pairing, because 102 of McCaffrey's touches last year were passes, and the field is building it the other way around.

Juszczyk at $1,400 is the classic showdown salary-saver: 10.4% owned, 2.3 projected, a finger injury on the report, and one or two red-zone snaps a game that Kyle Shanahan has drawn up for a decade.

Wide Receiver

Mike Evans, 33, signed a three-year deal with San Francisco this offseason coming off his first sub-1,000-yard season, and his camp was quad, then groin, then an abductor tag. If he plays he is the WR1 by default: $8,200 for 11.4 points at 22.9% ownership, with the third-best captain leverage on DraftKings at plus 0.9 because almost nobody is captaining him. The rookie is the more interesting price. De'Zhaun Stribling, the 33rd pick, caught seven balls for 63 yards in the first half of his preseason debut and 11 for 109 across two games before Shanahan sat him for the finale, and Shanahan said he "liked how his hands looked out there and played physical." He is $6,600 for 8.5 points at 19.8% ownership. Deebo Samuel, whom 49ers Webzone's roster capsule now calls a possession receiver, is $7,000 for 8.0 at 13.7%, and Demarcus Robinson at $3,800 is nearly unrostered at 0.9%.

Tight End

Kittle at $7,400 projects to 9.3 points on DraftKings at 17.0% ownership with neutral leverage, which is the Sims' way of saying the field has priced the Achilles correctly. Eight months from the tear to game week is fast, and a limited tag on Tuesday of game week means the snap count is the question, not the availability. Jake Tonges, who caught 34 passes with five touchdowns as the TE2 last year, is $4,400 at 4.6% ownership, the cheapest way to own San Francisco's red-zone tight end snaps if Kittle's count comes in low.

Kicker And Defense

Eddy Pineiro has made 25 straight field goals. The Sims have him at $4,800 for 7.9 points, but the ownership is 18.3% against a 15.2% optimal rate, so he is the kicker the field takes and Mevis is the kicker the Sims take. The 49ers D/ST at $3,400 projects to 4.6 and is rostered in 3.9% of lineups.

The Board: Sims Projections And Ownership On Both Sites

Flex and AnyFlex salaries shown. Captain and MVP cost 1.5 times the salary and score 1.5 times the points. Ownership is the Sims' projected field ownership for the flex slots; captain ownership is quoted in the prose where it decides something.

The row to read twice is Terrance Ferguson's FanDuel line. At $2,400 he is the cheapest pass-catcher on that site with a real role, and the field has him in 34.0% of FanDuel lineups, more than Adams, more than Evans, the sixth-highest ownership on the board. On DraftKings, where he costs $3,200 and Parkinson is $400 more, the field splits the two tight ends almost evenly. A $2,400 salary is doing the work on FanDuel that a target share would normally do, and the Sims' optimal rate for him there, 31.9%, says the field is right to take him but slightly over on it. He belongs in lineups on both sites; he just is not leverage on FanDuel the way his price suggests.

The Captain Question: Why The Leverage Column Belongs To A Kicker

Every showdown comes down to who you pay 1.5x for, and here the field has an answer: Nacua at 26.0% captain ownership on DraftKings, McCaffrey at 18.9%, and a long drop to Purdy at 10.8%. On FanDuel the MVP split is Nacua 20.2%, Purdy 19.1%, Stafford 13.2% and McCaffrey 13.1%. In a game nobody has played at this hour or on this field, the field is paying for the four players it knows.

The Sims do not dispute who the best players are. Nacua is the highest-projected player on the slate and McCaffrey is second. Where they disagree is on who wins the tournament, and the answer is the two San Francisco players whose leverage is positive in both DraftKings slots: Purdy at captain and McCaffrey at either. The driver is the depleted receiver room. With Pearsall, Kirk and Aiyuk gone, a 49ers scoring drive at the MCG runs through Purdy to McCaffrey more often than to any other 49er, and a quarterback captain paired with his own pass-catching back is the kind of correlation the field builds for the Rams and not for the dog. The receivers the 49ers left behind are why the captain slot is theirs.

Then there is the kicker. Mevis projects to 9.4 points on both sites, which on DraftKings is more than Kittle, Corum, or any tight end, and he does it for $5,000 flex. The DraftKings gap I walked through in the Rams capsule is 17.4; on FanDuel it is 24.1, off 43.7% optimal against 19.6% owned. The next-largest on either board is Corum at 3.1 and 2.0. The logic is the one showdown players relearn every week and forget by Sunday: in a game the market expects to be decided by a field goal, with the favorite implied for 26 points behind a kicker who missed one field goal after taking the job in November, the kicker is the projection the Sims keep buying at a salary that pays for a star somewhere else. The light winds from the top of the page are the rest of the case. Kicking at the MCG on a still, dry morning climbing out of the 40s toward a 63-degree afternoon is a clean environment for a kicker who has missed one field goal since taking the job.

I am not captaining a kicker, and at 1.0% of optimal captain slots neither are the Sims. But a Purdy captain lineup that spends $5,000 on Mevis instead of $7,400 on Kittle gets Nacua and McCaffrey both, and that is the build.

One DraftKings Build Example: Captain Purdy, $48,700

The lineup takes the two highest projections on the board as flex plays, pays for its difference at captain, and funds it with the three cheap Rams the Sims like: the kicker, the second back, and the tight end whose leverage is neutral rather than negative. It has four Rams and two 49ers, which satisfies DraftKings' one-from-each-team rule, and it leaves $1,300 unspent on purpose. The one upgrade the money buys, Ferguson to Parkinson for $400, costs three points of leverage without adding projection, because the Sims' optimal rate on Parkinson is 19.7% against Ferguson's 23.0%, and Kyren Williams for Corum costs $4,000 the lineup does not have. What this build gives up is Stafford, and in a game the Rams are favored to win that is a real cost. If you want the favorite's quarterback, the swap is Nacua out for Stafford in, which saves $1,400 and, with the $1,300 already unspent, pays to move Mevis up to Kittle. The lineup is then Captain Purdy, Stafford, McCaffrey, Kittle, Corum and Ferguson at $49,700, both quarterbacks and no Nacua, a construction the field almost never builds. It also gives up the kicker, which is the trade.

FanDuel is the better expression of the whole thesis, because the Mevis gap is wider there: 43.7% optimal against 19.6% owned, a leverage of 24.1 against 17.4 on DraftKings. The MVP slot goes to McCaffrey rather than Purdy because the field has Purdy at 55.3% in the flex on FanDuel and McCaffrey's MVP leverage of plus 2.5 is the best on that board. The lineup is MVP McCaffrey at $19,500, then Purdy $10,600, Nacua $12,400, Corum $7,600, Mevis $6,400 and Ferguson $2,400, which totals $58,900 against the $60,000 cap and projects to 85.6 points. The $1,100 left over does not reach a swap worth making; Ferguson to Higbee is a leverage move, not an upgrade, and it costs $1,400.

Showdown Rankings: Top 10, Secondary Plays And Lottery Tickets

Everything on this page that says optimal or leverage is a tournament number. For head-to-head and double-up lineups, build from projection and floor and ignore the leverage column, Mevis included. The rankings are ordered by projection with the two leverage plays moved up, which is how I would rank them for single-entry and three-max tournaments. If you are building 20 or more lineups, the ownership column above matters more than the order here, and correlation is the whole game: a captain quarterback wants a pass-catcher, a captain pass-catcher wants his quarterback.

Top 10 NFL DFS Showdown Picks

• Puka Nacua ($11,200 DK / $12,400 FD): Highest projection on DraftKings, third on FanDuel behind McCaffrey and Purdy, and the reason to keep at least one lineup built around the favorite's passing game. The field captains him; the Sims flex him.
• Christian McCaffrey ($10,600 / $13,000): Positive leverage in both DraftKings slots and the best MVP leverage on FanDuel, where the field has him at 47.1% in the flex. 102 catches last year, before the room emptied; the 2026 version of that number should be bigger, not smaller.
• Brock Purdy ($9,400 / $10,600): Third-highest projection, the cheapest of the four stars, and 10.8% captain ownership on DraftKings. The captain in my build.
• Matthew Stafford ($9,800 / $11,400): The MVP, the favorite, and the most over-owned player on the slate. Flex him with Nacua or leave him.
• Harrison Mevis ($5,000 / $6,400): Projects above every tight end, misses almost never, and the day's forecast is light winds. The largest leverage gap on the board.
• Blake Corum ($4,600 / $7,600): A 30% snap share priced like a backup on DraftKings. Second-best leverage on both sites.
• Kyren Williams ($8,600 / $10,200): Three straight 1,000-yard seasons, but the touches went from 21.9 a game to 17.4 and the price did not follow.
• Mike Evans ($8,200 / $9,400): WR1 by default if he plays; watch tonight's final report. Almost nobody captains him.
• George Kittle ($7,400 / $8,200): Neutral leverage on DraftKings says the field priced the Achilles correctly there; on FanDuel the field is over him. Snap count is the risk.
• Terrance Ferguson ($3,200 / $2,400): A 17.5-yard depth of target on a tight end is a touchdown waiting to happen. Chalk on FanDuel, a coin flip with Parkinson on DraftKings.

Secondary NFL DFS Showdown Picks

• Davante Adams ($9,200 / $9,000): 14 of his 60 catches last year were touchdowns, which is the ceiling; 24.7% owned against 22.2% optimal on DraftKings is the Sims saying the field already pays for it.
• De'Zhaun Stribling ($6,600 / $7,200): Rookie, 11 catches in two preseason games, and a third-down target already per the roster capsule. The cheapest route to a real 49ers target share.
• Rams D/ST ($4,000 / $7,000): 47 sacks last regular season, then Garrett added, then Donald ruled out. Playable with anything except a Purdy captain.
• Eddy Pineiro ($4,800 / $6,800): 25 straight makes. The field's kicker, and the one who absorbs the field's kicker ownership; both kickers belong together only in the builds that assume two stalled red-zone drives a side.
• Colby Parkinson ($3,600 / $5,800): Same projection as Ferguson on DraftKings, worse leverage. The tiebreaker is $400 and the ownership.
• Deebo Samuel Sr. ($7,000 / $8,600): Possession receiver now, per the 49ers Webzone capsule. Positive leverage on FanDuel, owned at 11.5%.

Lottery Ticket NFL DFS Showdown Picks

• Tyler Higbee ($2,600 / $3,800): Rested Tuesday, in 14.4% of the Sims' top DraftKings lineups against 13.0% owned, and the third tight end in a three-tight-end offense.
• Jake Tonges ($4,400 / $4,400): Five touchdowns as the fill-in last year; 4.6% owned on DraftKings. The Kittle-snap-count hedge.
• Kyle Juszczyk ($1,400 / $2,200): A finger on the report, a decade of red-zone snaps, and a salary that unlocks a build.
• Konata Mumpfield ($1,200 / $2,600): The only Rams reserve receiver the field rosters in any volume, and the Sims are under it.
• Kaelon Black ($3,000 / $4,800) And Jordan James ($2,000 / $1,000): The 49ers' RB2 and RB3, viable only if the McCaffrey news turns.
• Demarcus Robinson ($3,800 / $5,400): Deep on the depth chart when the room is healthy; the room is not healthy.
• 49ers D/ST ($3,400 / $6,600): 3.9% owned against a 38-year-old quarterback who landed the day before, and the Sims are under even that at 3.0% optimal. A price-and-narrative dart, not a leverage play.

More on this: Patriots vs Seahawks Showdown DFS: The Opener's Captain Question · NFL DFS Hub: Every Live Stokastic NFL Page · NFL Week 1 DFS Picks 2026 · NFL DFS Strategy: A Quick-Start Guide From Awesemo · Stokastic NFL Early Bird Pricing: Lock In Before September 1

Before Lock

Three things move these numbers before 8:35 p.m. ET Thursday. The final injury report lands Wednesday evening in the United States, Thursday morning in Melbourne, and a questionable tag on Evans or a designation on Kittle moves ownership more than it moves projection; the Sims rerun once it is in. The Rams land Thursday morning local time, and whether Garrett is on the field touches this slate through Purdy's protection and the Rams D/ST price. And the captain ownership numbers, which the Sims publish separately from flex ownership, sharpen as lineups get built through Thursday; the NFL DFS projections, ownership and captain leverage in the DataHub refresh through lock, or you can try the Sims free before Friday morning at the MCG.

More Week 1 showdown coverage: the Week 1 injury updates page tracks every designation, the showdown strategy guide and the leverage explainer cover the captain multiplier and why leverage decides these slates, the showdown plays tool shows where the captain and flex numbers live, Wednesday's Patriots-Seahawks showdown is the sibling piece, and the market's line on this game sits on the Week 1 predictions board.

The game nobody has scouted is still a game the Sims have simulated tens of thousands of times, and the pattern that falls out is a simple one: the field will pay for the four names it knows and the favorite's quarterback, and the lineup the Sims keep building pays for the dog's quarterback, the dog's back, and the favorite's kicker.

Code MELBOURNE10 takes 10% off your first payment on any Stokastic NFL or All Access package, and the Melbourne showdown Sims are already live.

Get 10% off the Sims with code MELBOURNE10