MLB DFS Picks, Spotlight Pitchers & Top Stacks: Who is Tonight’s SP2?! (Sept. 17)

Wednesday brings afternoon action, leading to a 10-game featured slate locking at 6:40 p.m. ET on FanDuel and Yahoo. DraftKings is locking at 7:05 p.m. ET with an eight-game docket. The MLB DFS picks today are full of value, but you need to use the best tools in order to uncover them. Stokastic’s MLB DFS Sims optimizer and MLB DFS projections highlight the top stacks, best arms and high-upside one-offs to anchor your lineups.

MLB DFS Optimizer Picks Today: Spotlight Pitchers & Stacks

For a limited time, sign up for MLB DFS Core or Max Weekly with promo code EMAC25 and get it for 15% off!

MLB DFS Optimizer Picks Today: Spotlight Pitchers

Main Slate Primary Pitching Target: RHP Brandon Woodruff (MIL vs. LAA)

Brewers vs. Angels – 3.2 implied runs
First Pitch: 7:40 p.m. ET
$9,700 at DraftKings
$10,800
at FanDuel
$50 at Yahoo

The Stokastic MLB DFS Top Pitchers tool is giving good marks to RHP Brandon Woodruff after RHP Freddy Peralta racked up 10 strikeouts in six innings against Anaheim last night.

The Angels struck out 76 times in the last five games, with the righties in the Seattle rotation also making hay. Woodruff missed nearly two years after needed shoulder surgery, dealing with a couple of different setbacks during his recovery. He last pitched on Sep. 6 as the team elected to push back his last scheduled start a couple days for rest purposes. This makes sense since the Brewers are looking to make a deep postseason run and they have the best record in baseball, looking to hold off Philadelphia (1.5 games) and Chicago (five games) in the National League.

Woodruff recorded 94, 97, 89 and 85 pitches in his last four starts, though he was pulled with only one out in the fourth inning in the first and third games in this stretch. He cruised to six shutout innings in Pittsburgh in his last appearance, collecting eight strikeouts. Tonight, if he follows a similar path as the last five right-handed starters against Los Angeles, he should close out the fifth inning and have the strikeout upside, plus the backing of the Brew Crew offense, to post a strong DFS score.

Main Slate Secondary Pitching Target: RHP Jacob deGrom (TEX at HOU)

Rangers at Astros – 3.0 implied runs
First Pitch: 8:10 p.m. ET
$9,300 at DraftKings
10,200
at FanDuel
$51 at Yahoo

FanDuel and Yahoo have RHP Jack Flaherty in Detroit against the Cleveland Guardians and RHP Lucas Giolito in Boston against the Athletics as viable secondary targets. Flaherty has been in shaky form recently, though the back of the Cleveland lineup is crummy. The A’s have plenty of power, but it is going to be in the low 60s tonight at Fenway Park with a light breeze in from right field.

There are several other frontline starters toeing the rubber this evening, though none of them have particularly appealing matchups. Lefties Jesus Luzardo and Blake Snell are squaring off in Los Angeles. However, they are going against two of the top offenses in the Phillies and Dodgers.

https://www.stokastic.com/join/?sport=mlb

In New York, LHP David Peterson and the Mets are hosting the San Diego Padres. Peterson is a mid-tier option, though his recent form has been dodgy. Across his last seven appearances, his ERA increased from 2.83 to 3.77.

The 7.13 ERA is abysmal, but his 3.26 FIP and 3.20 xFIP do indicate substantial bad luck, as evidenced by his .388 batting average on balls in play and a very low 55.8% left-on-base rate.

Peterson celebrated his 30th birthday this weekend, and the late-bloomer still has been collecting plenty of strikeouts, with 43 in his 35.1 most recent innings. The projected lineup for the Padres has a slim .111 ISO against southpaws this season. However, these hitters also have a collective 15.1% strikeout rate, which does not help the DFS projections for Peterson.

In Houston RHP Jacob deGrom will be trying to close the gap against the Astros. Texas lost last night, and the Rangers are now 3.5 games behind Boston for the final wild card slot and four games behind the ‘Stros. There is an outside chance for Texas to catch the Seattle Mariners, who have a 4.5-game lead for the AL West, though that means besting Houston in this series and then hoping the M’s and Astros trade blows over the weekend while the Rangers gain ground against both teams.

The 37-year-old has been excellent this season, and though he is no longer at his apex powers, deGrom is still a top-20 pitcher game in and game out. Houston is without Isaac Paredes and Yordan Alvarez, but the lineup still has talent with Jose Altuve, Christian Walker and Jeremy Pena. The addition of Jesus Sanchez and Carlos Correa via trades and the callup of toolsy, though underdeveloped prospect Zach Cole also give the Astros more chances to survive against deGrom.

Tonight there is no obvious SP2, which does add to the fun for DFS tournament decisions. On DraftKings, RHPs Cristian Javier ($6,500) and Luis Gil are cheap tournament fliers against Texas and in Minnesota against the Twins.

MLB DFS Optimizer Picks Today: Top Stacks

Main Slate Secondary Target: New York Yankees

Yankees at Twins – 5.2 implied runs
First Pitch: 7:40 p.m. ET
Opposing Starter: RHP Taj Bradley
DK Top Stack %: 12.9%
FD Top Stack %: 10.2%

The Stokastic MLB DFS Top Stacks Tool has bestowed good ratings for both sides of the Coors Field Extravaganza, even though game-time temperatures will be around 60 degrees with a light 7 to 10 mph breeze coming in from left-center field. LHP Ryan Weathers is starting for Miami, and RHP McCade Brown leads the hometown nine.

The results have been all over the place this season for RHP Taj Bradley. Last year he was solid, and it looked like he would level up. However, a lack of consistent strikeouts and potentially the venue change from Tropicana Field to Steinbrenner Field exacerbated the cracks in his skillset. Ultimately, Tampa sent him down to Triple-A before trading him to the Minnesota Twins, who kept him with Triple-A St. Paul for three more starts.

Through a scheduling quirk, his last start i, The Show for Tampa was against the Chicago White Sox, who he has now faced twice with Minnesota. In his last five big league games, he had a 7.43 ERA, a 5.06 FIP and a 5.01 xFIP, accompanied by a lackluster 7.43 strikeouts per nine, which are in line with his full-season rate. The 24-year-old had a strong 26.5% combined strikeout rate last season, cratering to a 20.3% rate this year. One silver lining in a sky filled with storm clouds is an improvement against same-handed hitters, limiting power with a .120 ISO as compared to a .171 ISO last year.

Of course, that is not going to save him against the likes of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton, who will be interspersed with left-handed boppers Trent Grisham, Ben Rice, Jazz Chisholm Jr., Cody Bellinger and Ryan McMahon.

Keep tabs on the forecast as there is a chance for rain tonight, though the current modeling has the system missing Minneapolis.


Stokastic’s MLB DFS Single Lineup Simulator is a game-changing tool that transforms lineup construction through powerful, data-driven simulations — essential for serious DFS players. See how the Simulator analyzes this single lineup for this sample MLB DFS slate using 10% randomness:


Main Slate Contrarian Target: Seattle Mariners

Mariners at Royals – 4.4 implied runs
First Pitch: 7:40 p.m. ET
Opposing Starter: RHP Cole Ragans
DK Top Stack %: 7.5%
FD Top Stack %: 5.3%

LHP Cole Ragans has been out since the first week of June with a strained rotator cuff. He made two rehabilitation starts, logging 45 and 56 pitches, so it would be a shock to see much more than 60 to 65 tonight. The 27-year-old started his breakout in 2023, with Texas trading him to Kansas City for reliever Aroldis Chapman, who helped the Rangers win the World Series.

Seattle cruised to a 10th consecutive victory last night as catcher Cal Raleigh tied Ken Griffey Jr. for the team record with his 55th and 56th home runs. Dominic Canzone had a trio of taters himself, which set the tone for the 12-5 victory.

The Mariners project to account for around 5% of all stacks tonight, which gives them tournament appeal. Canzone, of course, only starts against right-handed hurlers, so he will likely give way to Victor Robles. Focusing on the right-handed batsmen is key, along with switch-hitters in Raleigh and Jorge Polanco. Julio Rodriguez, Eugenio Suarez and Randy Arozarena round out the core options.

Kansas City also is in play as an overlooked option against RHP Bryce Miller. Yes, Miller is coming off a career-high 11 strikeouts, though that was against the Angels. He also allowed four earned runs and a pair of round-trippers, having now surrendered home runs in nine straight starts. In this stretch, he allowed a 7.00 ERA, a 6.34 FIP and 4.63 xFIP. These outings surround a trip to the injured list due to elbow discomfort, with offseason surgery required to clean up floating bone fragments that have plagued him all year.

Look to the top of the order for Kansas City, where Bobby Witt Jr., Vinnie Pasquantino, Miguel Garcia, Mike Yastrzemski and Salvador Perez are the most desirable options. Looking to duos or trios from both teams should provide plenty of differentiation for lineups centered around the Yankees or the Coors Field Extravaganza.

Today’s Top Sports Betting Picks

If you’re serious about making sharp MLB DFS picks, you already know that long-term success starts with using the right information. The same approach applies to sports betting — and that’s where Tails By OddsShopper shines.

Take a bet like Ryan McMahon to hit a home run tonight. On the surface, it’s a simple play. But behind the scenes, it’s a +EV bet, meaning it’s mathematically profitable based on the best odds available. With Tails, you can follow experts who provide tons of other +EV bets just like this. Upgrade to full Tails packages to join expert Discords, or check out the Free Picks page for daily updates.

Digging into the details on Portfolio EV, Wells is currently listed at +700 on DraftKings to take one out of the park, but he is only +400 on Hard Rock. That is a swing from a 24.2% expected ROI all the way down to a negative 20.1% expected ROI compared to the +554 “true odds.”

Home runs are fickle, but it is crazy to not shop for the best odds, as these can be a sucker’s bet when comparing you the best and the worst lines available. Keep in mind that McMahon was hitting in the heart of the order for Colorado before being traded to the Yankees. He is able to hide in the bottom third of the lineup, typically getting better pitches than the awesome gauntlet before him.


How to get the most out of your MLB DFS picks with Stokastic Sims — it’s more than just an MLB DFS optimizer! Also, check out Stokastic’s best DFS podcasts for more information every day. Click here for the best MLB DFS podcast!

 

 

Eric "EMac" MacPherson won the 2007 Fantasy Baseball grand prize (trip for two to the MLB All-Star game) in the Roto format on ESPN. He won again in 2008, this time in the H2H format. As one of the early adopters of daily fantasy sports, EMac has been providing content for baseball and basketball as well as both professional and college football since 2012 for a variety of websites including DraftKings Playbook, FanVice, RotoWorld, Daily Fantasy Bootcamp, and RotoGrinders. He is well into his third decade of fantasy sports and has a wealth of knowledge and experience. Follow him on Twitter @EMacDFS or contact EMac by emailing [email protected].

Premium Data

MLB DFS Ownership Projections: Night Slate

MLB DFS Ownership Projections: Early Slate

DraftKings MLB DFS Top Stacks Tool

MLB DFS Ownership Projections: Main Slate

MLB DFS Top Stack % for FanDuel

MLB DFS Top Stack % for Yahoo

Top Batters Tool: DraftKings

DFS Winners from the Stokastic Community

Subscribe to the Stokastic newsletter

DFS advice, exciting promos, and the best bets straight to your inbox

Stokastic.com - Daily Fantasy Sports and Sports Betting Data, Tools, & Analytics

Please play responsibly. Only customers 21 and over are permitted to play. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.